Accommodations and modifications are both strategies used to support ELL/bilingual students in their academic assessments, but they have distinct differences and purposes.

Accommodations involve providing support to enable ELL/bilingual students to access the assessment tool while maintaining the same learning expectations as their English-speaking peers. Accommodations do not alter the content or level of difficulty of the assessment but rather focus on providing linguistic or instructional supports to help students demonstrate their knowledge and skills effectively. Examples of accommodations for ELL/bilingual students include extended time, bilingual dictionaries or glossaries, use of graphic organizers or visual aids, simplified test instructions, and preferential seating.

On the other hand, modifications involve altering the content, expectations, or administration of the assessment itself to better fit the individual needs and abilities of ELL/bilingual students. This may involve adapting the material or level of difficulty, reducing the number of questions, allowing for alternative responses, or providing different assessment formats altogether. For instance, a modification might be providing a simplified reading passage, allowing the use of native language response, or assessing through visual or oral presentations instead of written tests.

Determining whether to use accommodations or modifications for a particular student depends on factors such as the student's language proficiency, academic abilities, and specific needs. It is essential to consider the student's individualized education program (IEP) or English language development (ELD) plan, as well as input from ELL/bilingual specialists, teachers, and parents. Moreover, ongoing monitoring and assessment of the student's progress and needs are crucial to determine the effectiveness of the chosen strategies and make adjustments accordingly.

Here are two scholarly resources that discuss accommodations and modifications for ELL/bilingual students:

1. Calderón, M., Slavin, R., & Sánchez, M. (2011). Effective Instruction for English Learners. The Future of Children, 21(1), 103-127.
This article provides evidence-based practices and strategies for supporting English learners, including various accommodations and modifications for assessments.

2. Rivera, C., & Collum, H. L. (2018). Linguistic Accommodations for English Language Learners: A Systematic Review of Literature. Middle Grades Research Journal, 13(1), 63-79.
This systematic review explores linguistic accommodations for ELL students, focusing on assessment accommodations and their impact on student outcomes.

Please note that due to the limitations of the AI system, I cannot provide the full citations or access to the full texts of the articles. However, you should be able to find these resources through academic databases or by searching the provided titles and authors' names.

Got a question with my answer?

Message Me

Cheapmath.com is completely free!

Asking question is free. Getting answers is free.

+99

Continue