Doreen is delivering a speech on the topic of donating money to help feed the children of AIDS victims in Africa. She set up her speech using Monroe’s motivated sequence. She sails through attention, needs, and satisfaction. She starts delivering her visualization step, and she goes a little crazy. She claims that if more people would donate to this cause, the world would be devoid of hunger, children in Africa could all get an education, and we could establish world peace. She then makes claims that not feeding the children of AIDS victims in Africa could lead to world chaos and nuclear war.
1. Is it ethical to create unrealistic expectations during the visualization step?
2. Should you try to exaggerate the visualization stage if you know, realistically, that the possible outcomes are not that impressive?
3. If Doreen was your friend, how would you respond to this section of her speech? Should you point out that her argument is unethical?
Guide On Rating System
Vote
1. No, it is not ethical to create unrealistic expectations during the visualization step. Presenting exaggerated or false claims can mislead and deceive the audience, compromising their trust in the speaker and the cause being presented.
2. No, one should not exaggerate the visualization stage if the possible outcomes are not that impressive. It is important to present information and arguments accurately and honestly to maintain credibility and trustworthiness.
3. If Doreen was your friend, it would be appropriate to kindly point out that her argument is unethical. You can explain that it is important to provide realistic and truthful information to the audience, and that exaggerating claims can damage the credibility of the cause and lead to misunderstandings or disappointments. Encourage her to focus on presenting accurate and reliable information in order to engage the audience effectively.