Home>Homework Answsers>History homework help>American history homework help
Consider the following statement: "In preparing for the Cherokee removal, state and federal officials were motivated solely by desire to seize the natives' land." In your post, consider the following:
Does this statement present the full picture? Revise this statement to present a more complex explanation of the motivations that drove state and federal officials (and the white citizens of Georgia) during the years immediately preceding the Cherokee removal. Explain the choices you made in your revision.
Next, consider how you can take a similar approach to your own topic in order to more fully understand the historical complexity. What other viewpoints would you want to further explore in order to more fully understand your topic?
Guide On Rating System
Vote
The statement, "In preparing for the Cherokee removal, state and federal officials were motivated solely by desire to seize the natives' land," presents a one-dimensional view of the motivations behind the Cherokee removal. While the desire for land certainly played a significant role, it is important to consider a more complex explanation of the motivations that drove state and federal officials, as well as white citizens of Georgia, during this time.
Revised statement: "In preparing for the Cherokee removal, state and federal officials, along with the white citizens of Georgia, were driven by a combination of factors including the desire for land, economic interests, racism, and a sense of racial superiority."
In my revision, I included additional motivations to present a more comprehensive view of the topic. By highlighting economic interests, such as the potential for agricultural expansion and access to natural resources on Cherokee lands, it acknowledges the economic incentive for officials and citizens to support the removal.
Furthermore, including racism and a sense of racial superiority as motivations acknowledges the prevalent attitudes of the time. Many white Americans at that time believed in the concept of Manifest Destiny, which promoted the idea that white settlers were destined to expand across the continent. This belief system often included the notion that Native Americans were inferior and needed to be removed from their ancestral lands.
To more fully understand the historical complexity of any topic, it is essential to consider multiple viewpoints. In the case of the Cherokee removal, exploring the perspective of the Cherokee Nation and their resistance to forced removal would provide valuable insight. Additionally, analyzing the role of political ideologies, such as the debate between states' rights and federal authority, can offer a deeper understanding of the motivations behind the removal.
In order to more fully understand my own topic, I would want to explore the viewpoints of different social and political groups involved, as well as any economic or ideological factors that may have influenced their actions. By examining these various perspectives and motivations, I can gain a more comprehensive understanding of the historical complexities at play.
Got a question with my answer?
Cheapmath.com is completely free!
Asking question is free.
Getting answers is free.
+99